New Commonhold Bill gives owners more control than under Right to Manage – but remains very weak

I welcome the Commonhold and Leasehold Reform Bill published today, albeit much delayed and watered down. It will give commonhold flat owners more say over how their buildings are run, but does little to improve the acessibility of Right to Manage or the power of leaseholders in a RTM company. It leaves a question that matters at Chelsea Bridge Wharf, unanswered. What happens when a small group of owners takes control of the board and the majority of owners are largely excluded from decisons about how the development is managed?

At Chelsea Bridge Wharf, the UK’s largest Right to Manage development (1130 units approx) I have evidenced that leaseholders have no more control over what they pay in service charges now than they did before Right to Manage. Read my earlier article on service charges at Chelsea Bridge Wharf.

What commonhold would give owners

The clearest improvement is the right to vote on the annual budget and reserve fund contributions. Where a vote is required, at least half of those voting must vote in favour. Directors cannot demand payment under a proposal that requires approval and fails to get it. Building safety expenditure is excluded from the vote, and regulations can set other exceptions and fallback rules. Read the Bill, Schedule 4.

The government plans annual director elections through regulations. It also envisages an AGM, although the Bill itself contains no express requirement to hold one. Owners can organise to replace a managing agent, but the Bill gives them no automatic vote on every appointment or renewal. The association’s rules and the management contract will still matter. Read the government’s guide.

Where turnout is low, a small, organised group can still win elections and dominate the board. The Bill does give owners more ways to intervene. An individual owner could ask the First-tier Tribunal in England to remove a director who has materially breached their duties. The tribunal could also appoint a replacement. That matters when an owner cannot muster enough votes to change the board and can show a material breach. Read the Bill, clauses 23 and 24.

Leaseholder/Owner PowerProposed commonholdExisting Right to Manage
Can owners vote on the annual budget?Generally, yes. At least half of those voting must approve the proposed budget and reserve fund contributions where a vote is required. Building safety expenditure is excluded. Regulations can provide for other exceptions and fallback rules.The Bill gives RTM members no new right to approve the budget or reserve fund contributions.
Must directors face election every year?The government plans annual elections through regulations. Members can choose professional directors if owners do not volunteer.The Bill introduces no annual election requirement for RTM directors.
Can owners choose or replace the managing agent?Owners can organise to replace an agent. The association’s rules and management contract govern the process. The Bill gives the association a right to terminate certain long-term contracts agreed during the developer’s initial period.The Bill gives RTM members no new right to vote directly on the choice of agent.
Must there be an AGM?The government envisages an AGM. Existing prescribed commonhold articles already require one. The Bill contains no express AGM requirement for the new system.The Bill introduces no AGM requirement for RTM companies.
Can an individual ask the tribunal to remove a director?Yes. Clause 24 allows an individual owner to apply but only where a director has materially breached their duties, which is a very high bar. The Bill gives RTM members no equivalent tribunal route. Existing company law allows members to vote to remove a director at a general meeting but there is no obligation on the RTM company to hold such meetings. RTM members can call an emergency general meeting but the system is heavily loaded in favour of incumbent directors (those currently in post)

Right to Manage needs the same safeguards as Commonhold

The 2025 reforms made it easier to claim Right to Manage (RTM) and capped landlords’ voting power in English RTM companies. The new Bill leaves the relationship between RTM directors and leaseholders largely as it is. It gives members no new right to approve the budget, elect directors annually, insist on an AGM or vote on the choice of managing agent. It also gives them no equivalent of the new commonhold route to ask a tribunal to remove a director for a material breach. Members can already use company law to call a general meeting if they have at least 5% of the voting rights, and can vote to remove a director at a meeting, subject to special notice. 2025 RTM voting reforms · Companies Act 2006.

At Chelsea Bridge Wharf, that means the Bill gives leaseholders no new right to vote on our service charge budget or on whether to retain Urang. As I argued in my letter to The i Paper, RTM companies should have the same democratic checks and balances as commonhold associations. That should include annual elections, a meaningful AGM where members can ask questions, a vote on the budget and an accessible way to challenge directors who fail to meet their duties. I would also give members a clear right to vote on the managing agent under both systems. Read my letter to The i Paper.

How affordable will conversion be?

The Bill would make commonhold the default for most new flats, with exemptions. Existing leases will continue unless the development converts. The proposed route generally requires support from at least half of qualifying leaseholders. Where leaseholders need to buy the freehold to convert, they still have to find the money. I expect RTM to remain the main practical route for many leaseholders to take control for years to come. Read the government’s guide to conversion.

The Bill does little to make Right to Manage easier to obtain. To claim RTM or to use the statutory right to buy the freehold collectively, qualifying leaseholders representing at least 50% of the flats in the building generally have to take part. Getting that level of participation can be difficult, especially on a large development. Buying the freehold is many times more difficult because it also means raising enough money to pay the purchase price and cover professional fees, which can put it out of reach even where there is enough support in principle. Right to Manage eligibility · Collective freehold purchase eligibility. In my view only a small percentage of leasehold developments will be able to convert to commonhold and thus RTM will remain the main vehicle to take back some cintrol, for many years to come.

The government still says its reforms will make freehold purchases and lease extensions cheaper, including by abolishing marriage value. But on 17 November, housing minister Matthew Pennycook told Parliament that the government could not use the new valuation rates themselves to lower premiums further. Harry Scoffin of Free Leaseholders argues that setting both rates at 9% would make buying a freehold or extending a lease more affordable. The government has yet to decide the rates. In my view, Pennycook’s answer narrows what leaseholders can expect from this part of the reform. Pennycook’s parliamentary answer · Free Leaseholders’ campaign.

The Bill can still be amended as it makes its way through Parliament. Parliament should use this opportunity to strengthen leaseholders’ control of RTM companies. People should be able to hold their directors to account and have a meaningful say over what they pay, whether they live in a development run by an RTM company or in a commonhold.